
I find that some of the best places to eat are never easily seen straight off the main road. In fact, you may have to travel back in time with Chris Lloyd to a near abandoned town to get there. "GREAT SCOTT!". Along route 441 driving south from Gainesville, you'll eventually come upon a small town called Micanopy. Turn right onto the only flashing traffic light for miles and you're there. According to their town website, its referred to as the " town that time forgot" and by visiting it you can see that statement to be all too true. The town is absolutely Historic, like the mansion hotel you can still book rooms in that was built in 1845. Micanopy is a town of roughly 700 people and is rarely ever disturbed. It reminds me of the small town in the film "Big Fish" in which you come and their pie and then never leave because the people are just so damn nice! With every nice small town, comes its oddities. Every time I take a trip to Micanopy for lunch, i stop to eat and then wander into the antique shops and general stores for fun .Among my discoveries over the years, I found an old gas mask from WWII, action figures from the 40's and 50's and an ancient enema kit. Why anyone would want to purchase the enema kit, I've no idea. But it looked very uncomfortable and I got a good laugh out of it.
But despite these quirky little shops and disturbing discoveries, there lies a small cafe that everyone can relax at and eat a good lunch. In fact, it is half cafe and half antique store. Almost every building in micanopy is an antique store in some strange way. While you're ordering, don't hesitate to take a look around you. From ceiling to floor, this place is covered in old novelties. The food, however, is very fresh. Old Florida Cafe is a small sandwich shop settled among a patio garden. Everytime I go I have unique experience and strangely take on a Southern accent. Their specialties include reubans, cubans, and BLTs. They are simple sandwiches that aren’t so simple when entering the mouth. The Reuben’s are smothered in corn beef cheese and sauerkraut . I know it sounds simple, but sometimes less is more.The BLT- just as it sounds. The best part about this is that the bacon is actually still sizzling and crispy when it makes its way to your plate. My friend ordered this and the bacon was actually glistening. Lets face it, one of the things that Southern folk can do is fry bacon. Fry Bacon and make the best sweet tea. Another great part about this hidden gem is that the sweet tea is also made every day. Served in a styrofoam cup with a huge chunk of ice stuck in the bottom to suck on later, drowned to the top with tea. Am I crazy or do drinks taste better in styrofoam? Everyday at the cafe feels like a lazy Sunday. And while you’re still hungry, grab some cakes and pies that peek at you in the window when you are ordering at the counter. (Warning: Pecan pie may cause involuntary drooling).
Don't be surprised however to have visitors while you’re eating. No, im not talking about cranky panhandling hobos. Im talking about the cats. It is widely know that the cafe's cat with a lazy eye and a chipped ear makes its way systematically around from table to table as the food is served. Using his unbareable cuteness, you'll soon notice that he'll usually get a piece of food from every table he visits. There are actually a couple of cats that wander the town hoping to get stray scraps. Oh, and they also love to be pet.
Sitting under your umbrella table eating your scrumptualities, you can look on the town. It feels like the town was literally forgotten, and that the people never left. The buildings are old with the paint scraping off. You’ll find small dirt roads crisscrossing in and out of the road like Peach and Magnolia Avenue. The people there take their time.It's comforting to know that simple places like this still exist despite cities with useless traffic jams and iphone takeovers. If you come to Old Florida Cafe, you'll feel it to be an absolute escape.
****Remember that Old Florida Cafe takes cash only, but prices are very reasonable.